Imagine knowing that just by pointing a telescope at a specific place in the sky, you’ll be the first to ever see an undiscovered planet. That’s what happened in 1846, when astronomer Johann Galle first spotted Neptune, exactly where mathematicians had predicted it would be. All other planets had been visible from the night sky and known about since antiquity, except Uranus, which was unintentionally discovered when William Herschel happened to notice it while looking through his telescope. That meant Neptune’s discovery was the first time a planet had been found not by accident or a lucky coincidence, but by mathematical prediction. Using Newton’s laws, mathematicians were able to both identify that a planet existed beyond Uranus and figure out exactly where it would be.

In 1781, William Herschel discovered Uranus, the first new planet observed since prehistoric times. While cataloging stars, he noticed an interesting object that he initially believed to be a comet, but further observation revealed that it lacked many of the distinctive traits of comets, like having a tail, and that it might actually be a planet. Old records were re-examined, and it was discovered that Uranus had been observed many times in the past by different astronomers, who had documented it as a normal star rather than a planet. Most surprisingly, it may have been seen as early as 128 BC, when Hipparchos seemed to have included it in his star catalog. With this, Uranus was confirmed to be a planet, and scientists were able to calculate an estimated orbit for it.

At first, everything seemed fine, but after a few decades of observation, they noticed something odd. The orbit of Uranus was slightly off from predictions, seemingly making it violate Newton’s laws of universal gravitation. But Newton’s laws weren’t wrong, meaning something else was at play: an unseen planet pulling on Uranus. Based on this assumption, mathematicians would then be able to apply Newton’s laws to the observed movement of Uranus and predict where this mystery planet might be. That’s exactly what they did, which is how we found Neptune.

Le Verrier

Adams
So, who were the people who actually found Neptune? There were two major discoverers, Urbain Le Verrier in France and John Couch Adams in England. They were both able to treat Uranus’s orbit as a math problem: given its deviations from predictions, could they calculate the mass and orbit of an unknown planet?
Adams and Le Verrier were able to calculate Neptune’s orbit by comparing Uranus’s actual path to its predicted one. If Uranus’s actual longitude didn’t match its predicted one, the difference had to be caused by a gravitational perturbation (essentially a disturbance caused by another planet). To put it simply, they modeled this pull using a method similar to the equation $\Delta r \sim \frac{Gm’}{d^2} f(\theta)$, where $m’$ was the mass of the new planet, $d$ its distance, and $f(\theta)$ a factor for orbital geometry, accounting for the relative positions of Uranus and the unknown planet. By adjusting these unknowns, they tried to make Uranus’s observed “errors” disappear. Once they did, they would know both the mass of the unknown planet and its distance from Uranus, making it much easier to find.
Adams completed his calculations earlier than Le Verrier, but Le Verrier’s were the ones that were published first and led to Neptune being observed. Their final predictions were quite similar, placing Neptune at around $325^\circ$ ecliptic longitude. Adams sent his results to George Airy, the Astronomer Royal, but Airy was unconvinced and never ordered a search. Only after Le Verrier published similar figures did Airy ask James Challis at Cambridge to look, but Challis, working without an up-to-date star map, did not realize Neptune was a planet despite seeing it twice in August of 1846. Le Verrier, meanwhile, sent his results to Johann Galle in Berlin, who on September 23, 1846, aimed his telescope where the planet was expected to be. Within one degree of Le Verrier’s prediction, Neptune appeared.
The discovery of Neptune was not without controversy, and it soon became a matter of national pride. Similar to the calculus controversy over Newton and Leibniz, the discovery of Neptune became a controversy of its own, with Britain rallying around Adams and France championing Le Verrier. It was a difficult question: should more credit be given to the one who did the math first, or the one who communicated his work better and sparked the actual discovery? Today, Le Verrier is generally given primary credit, since his prediction was published first and directly led to Neptune being observed, while Adams is recognized as an independent co-predictor who reached similar conclusions on his own.
Beyond this debate, there’s also a theory that neither Adams nor Le Verrier was the first discoverer, and that Galileo had observed Neptune over a hundred years earlier. This isn’t entirely impossible, since Galileo could have accidentally stumbled upon it, similarly to how Herschel stumbled upon Uranus. However, the evidence for Galileo observing Neptune is shaky at best, and even if you believe he did see Neptune, it’s unclear if he recognized it as a planet, meaning he isn’t generally recognized as the person who discovered Neptune.
The discovery of Neptune was more than just finding another planet: it was proof of the power of math. Based on minor irregularities in Uranus’s path, Le Verrier and Adams were able to reverse-engineer the orbit of an unseen planet. Their predictions, accurate to within a degree, showed how math and Newton’s laws could predict phenomena far beyond what humans could observe by themselves. For the first time, a new planet was found based on calculations rather than pure chance.
This article has a corresponding assignment on our Assignments page!